Traditions are memes. I understand some of why traditions are propagated... they keep cultures alive (maybe small-scale like in a fraternity or family unit, or maybe large scale like a national identity or a religion). What got me thinking about this was overhearing a snippet of conversation last night in which two couples were talking about what happens if a Jewish boy is born right at sunset... How do you know when to get the rabbinical specialist with the wine, strap-down board, and knife to show up... i.e. which is the eighth day. It turns out there is someone you can call. You give him/her the day and recorded minute of birth, and they will tell you if the boy was born before or after sunset from an almanac... but it got me wondering. The tradition of using the almanac might not be universal. There is a rich diversity of Jewish cultures, and many of them are fierce believers in doing things the old fashioned way, and others maybe less so. So I started wondering about whether in centuries (before almanacs and accurate clocks and telephones) gone by there might have been someone who's job it was to hang around the house of a woman in labor in the late afternoons to announce when the Sun had set, and perhaps someone else inside listening for that call and keeping an eye on how much of the baby had come out when the call was made. It also got me wondering what technically counts as sunset under these conditions. If you are in a house nestled in a deep valley, sunset might be an hour or more earlier than for a neighbor at the top of the hill. Is it the sunshine that matters? what do you do when it is raining?
Of course, there are lots of groups with traditions. Some are more whimsical that others. If someone violates a tradition connected to fans of some sports franchise... not really a big deal. Perhaps within political parties these traditions are as serious as religious ones. Nationally, we might now be starting a tradition of impeaching every two term president from here forward. Families might always take their vacation in the first two weeks of August, and always go to the same campground, and camp with the same friends they've always camped with...
But with every tradition that gets very specific about time, places, and actions, how do you handle cases near the boundaries and perhaps closer than our ability to measure? Do we have the calamity of Buridan's Ass? or do we shrug it off and make our best approximation? or do we close down shop and end the tradition (as mostly happened to the Abbey of Saint Pyr when Caw ap Rhys died)?
Oh well. Lots of loose thoughts and no possible resolution. I invite your comments.
Of course, there are lots of groups with traditions. Some are more whimsical that others. If someone violates a tradition connected to fans of some sports franchise... not really a big deal. Perhaps within political parties these traditions are as serious as religious ones. Nationally, we might now be starting a tradition of impeaching every two term president from here forward. Families might always take their vacation in the first two weeks of August, and always go to the same campground, and camp with the same friends they've always camped with...
But with every tradition that gets very specific about time, places, and actions, how do you handle cases near the boundaries and perhaps closer than our ability to measure? Do we have the calamity of Buridan's Ass? or do we shrug it off and make our best approximation? or do we close down shop and end the tradition (as mostly happened to the Abbey of Saint Pyr when Caw ap Rhys died)?
Oh well. Lots of loose thoughts and no possible resolution. I invite your comments.
Leave a comment






